Tim Maciel is a retired educator and college administrator with advanced degrees in administration, planning, and social policy. He is a former school board director with the Windham Southeast School District.
BRATTLEBORO-As a former language educator, I have always been interested in the relationship between words and ideas. Language does more than describe the world around us. It shapes how we understand it, what questions we ask, and sometimes what possibilities we can imagine.
Consider, for example, how phrases such as trickle-down economics and the 99 percent have influenced the way Americans think and talk about economic inequality. One promised that economic growth would eventually benefit everyone; the other, popularized by the Occupy Wall Street movement, challenges us to ask who was actually benefiting.
That power of language is one reason Amanda Janoo's candidacy for governor has changed the way I think of Vermont's future. Although she didn't win the election, she introduced many Vermonters to a vocabulary and a way of thinking that challenge deeply ingrained assumptions about our economy, our communities, and our future.
* * *
Consider the phrase well-being economy. It sounds simple enough, but it represents a significant shift from the way we traditionally measure economic success.
For decades, our political leaders in Montpelier have relied heavily on GDP, employment figures, business growth, and tax revenues as indicators of prosperity. These measures have their place, but they tell us relatively little about whether people are actually living better lives.
A well-being economy asks different questions. Can working families afford housing? Do children - all children - receive the quality education and support they need? Can people afford healthcare without financial hardship? Are our communities thriving? Are we protecting the natural environment that sustains us? And are we creating opportunities for future generations?
In other words, the economy should serve people, not the other way around.
* * *
Another phrase Janoo brought into our political conversation is managed decline. It's an uncomfortable expression, but that's precisely why it's useful. It challenges us to consider whether we're simply managing Vermont's problems rather than addressing their underlying causes.
When young people leave because they cannot afford housing, when homelessness continues to grow, when schools struggle to meet students' needs, when too many students fail to acquire basic skills, and when local businesses and communities lose vitality, we shouldn't automatically accept these developments as inevitable. That kind of resignation gets us nowhere. Instead, we need to think differently about the problems themselves.
Janoo encouraged us to see these challenges as interconnected rather than isolated policy issues. Housing affects health, education, and economic opportunity. Education affects workforce development and the vitality of our communities. Climate and energy decisions affect everything from household affordability to economic development. Addressing one problem without considering its relationship to others often produces disappointing results.
Education provides a particularly important example.
Vermont invests substantial public resources in its schools, yet we need to be more transparent and open about the results, especially for students with disabilities. Crista Yagjian, a member of Vermont's State Advisory Panel on Special Education, has reminded me that we need to look beyond overall achievement figures and ask whether our schools are meeting the needs of all students.
In July, the U.S. Department of Education rated Vermont "Needs Intervention" under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act Part B, a serious federal warning, following five consecutive years of "Needs Assistance."
At the 2022 baseline, only about 17% of Vermont fourth graders with individualized education programs (IEPs) were proficient in English language arts, and only 7% were proficient in mathematics. Graduation and dropout rates still fall short of targets. Federal findings also identify long-standing compliance issues that, in some districts, date back to 2019.
Yagjian argues that these findings should prompt some difficult questions.
Is our core instruction accessible to all students, including those with IEPs, through appropriate accommodations and high expectations? Do our schools practice inclusion in a meaningful way, so that students learn alongside their peers with the supports they need and not just share a room?
Are early interventions and specialized services reaching students before they fall far behind, and do we check that they work? And why does the achievement gap between students with IEPs and their peers remain so large?
These are not criticisms intended to blame educators, many of whom work extraordinarily hard under challenging circumstances. Rather, they are questions about whether our policies, resources, and institutional priorities are producing the opportunities our children deserve.
A well-being approach asks us to look beyond how much we spend and examine what difference our investments actually make.
Community schools, for example, recognize that children's educational experiences are inseparable from their physical health, emotional well-being, family circumstances, and the communities in which they live. Attracting and retaining excellent teachers, supporting innovative approaches to learning, and ensuring that students with disabilities are genuinely included are investments in Vermont's future.
Finally, Amanda Janoo offered us something equally important: a different understanding of democracy. Her emphasis on public participation, transparency, local initiatives, and economic decision-making that serves local communities challenges the notion that governing is primarily a top-down process.
Too often, decisions are made by political leaders and then handed down to the communities affected by them. Whether the issue is school governance, housing, energy development, or economic investment, the people most affected by public decisions should have a meaningful voice in shaping them.
* * *
This brings me back to Janoo's concession speech. She made an observation that has stayed with me: Her greatest opponent was never Phil Scott or another political party. It was cynicism - the belief that things cannot change, that our problems are too entrenched, and that imagining a different future is simply unrealistic. That, she argued, was the real challenge.
I believe she is right. Cynicism is easy because it relieves us of the responsibility to imagine alternatives and work toward them. Accepting the status quo is itself a political choice.
Amanda Janoo may not have won the governorship, but she has given many of us including, hopefully, our legislators, a new vocabulary for thinking about Vermont's future and, more importantly, good reason to question assumptions that have limited our political aspirations and imagination.
Perhaps the most important contribution of a political campaign is not always the policies it proposes or even the election it wins. Sometimes it is the questions it leaves us asking long after the campaign is over.
Vermonters have an opportunity to demonstrate that another kind of politics is possible: politics of, for, and by the people. That requires more than casting a ballot every few years. It means continuing to organize, showing up at public meetings, listening to one another, and holding those who govern us accountable.
The election is over. But the conversation about what kind of economy and what kind of Vermont we want to build is just beginning.
Let's not allow cynicism to have the last word.
This Voices Viewpoint was submitted to The Commons.
This piece, published in print in the Voices section or as a column in the news sections, represents the opinion of the writer. In the newspaper and on this website, we strive to ensure that opinions are based on fair expression of established fact. In the spirit of transparency and accountability, The Commons is reviewing and developing more precise policies about editing of opinions and our role and our responsibility and standards in fact-checking our own work and the contributions to the newspaper. In the meantime, we heartily encourage civil and productive responses at voices@commonsnews.org.