BRATTLEBORO

Weather

View 7-day forecast

Weather sponsored by

Keeping your community covered. Please help us reach our year-end goal.

Donate Now

Keeping your community covered. We're committed to producing high-quality, fact-based news and information that gives you the facts in this community we call home. If our work has helped you stay informed, take action, or feel more connected to Windham County – please give now to help us reach our goal of raising $150,000 by December 31st.

BRATTLEBORO

Weather

View 7-day forecast

Weather sponsored by

Keeping your community covered. Please help us reach our year-end goal.

Donate Now

Keeping your community covered. We're committed to producing high-quality, fact-based news and information that gives you the facts in this community we call home. If our work has helped you stay informed, take action, or feel more connected to Windham County – please give now to help us reach our goal of raising $150,000 by December 31st.

Voices

Holding the state accountable on its pro-nuclear agenda

EASTHAMPTON, MASS.-Following up on the commentary related to nuclear power [Voices, Nov. 4], the Citizens Awareness Network wants you to know how to keep abreast of new developments around the Vermont Yankee (VY) site.

Currently, your only option is Vernon Selectboard and Planning Commission meetings, and any meetings that PowerTransitions, the private company that has an option on the site’s development rights, may decide to hold.

Information how to attend when plans for the VY site are on the agenda can be found at vernonvt.org under the Government and Boards & Committees tabs.

At the Oct. 20 Selectboard meeting, Vermont Public Service Commissioner Kerrick Johnson spoke of the Scott administration’s hopes to take advantage of the infrastructure at the VY site and build a new nuclear reactor there.

He claimed that 63% of Vermonters were “strongly or somewhat supportive” of getting electricity from nuclear power. I was intrigued by this statistic and followed up with him.

He was citing “Vermont Weighs In,” a 2023 report on the attitudes of Vermonters based on a series of surveys and focus groups conducted by MassINC Polling Group for the state Department of Public Service. The commissioner acknowledged that he misspoke and that he should have said 58%.

The “Vermont Weighs In” report tells a bigger story than this one data point reveals.

Of the six energy sources examined in the survey, nuclear power came in dead last for combined “strongly or somewhat supportive” responses (55%, in fact) — after solar (84%), wind (90%), hydro (77%), burning methane gas (64%), and burning wood (62%).

This data indicates that Vermonters want to see renewables take a front seat in the state’s energy policy. The fact is that 22% of Vermont’s electricity already comes from Seabrook nuclear power station.

We say that is more than enough! Any additional state investment in expensive, dirty, and dangerous nuclear power will just steal resources away from expanding renewables.

Commissioner Johnson also said that nuclear energy can be part of a path to more affordable energy for Vermonters. The small modular reactors (SMRs) that the Scott administration champions are an unproven technology with no reliable, time-tested cost parameters.

It is irresponsible to equate “new nuclear” with “affordability,” especially since in recent weeks one SMR development project after another has been abandoned as too financially risky.

As Schuyler Gould’s recent letter [“Fundamentally undemocratic efforts to control state energy policy,” Letters, Nov. 4] pointed out, Commissioner Johnson has stated on numerous occasions that Vermonters should be able to determine the state’s energy future.

Yet the Scott administration is pushing to get rid of the law that requires a vote of the Legislature before nuclear power can run again within Vermont’s borders. After all the years of controversy over VY, requiring that the people’s representatives be heard in decisions about nuclear power is wisdom that should be honored.

Democracy is a two-way street; let’s show up to hold the Scott administration accountable!


Citizens Awareness Network

Easthampton, Mass.

Ann Darling


This letter to the editor was submitted to The Commons.

This piece, published in print in the Voices section or as a column in the news sections, represents the opinion of the writer. In the newspaper and on this website, we strive to ensure that opinions are based on fair expression of established fact. In the spirit of transparency and accountability, The Commons is reviewing and developing more precise policies about editing of opinions and our role and our responsibility and standards in fact-checking our own work and the contributions to the newspaper. In the meantime, we heartily encourage civil and productive responses at voices@commonsnews.org.

Subscribe to receive free email delivery of The Commons!