PUTNEY-Vermont’s business owners shape the state’s economy every day, noted Vermont Chamber of Commerce President Amy Spear.
But these employers stand at the edge of a gap. On one side, business owners stand ready to do more: hire, renovate their properties, and share Vermont’s exciting energy with the rest of the world.
On the other side of this trench sit unsupportive economic, regulatory, and staffing conditions.
“So that gap that we talk about is really where the work of the Vermont Chamber begins, and that’s why we’re really focused … on affordability and abundance,” Spear told members of the Brattleboro Regional Chamber of Commerce over lunch at Landmark College, Nov. 10.
Making Vermont more affordable requires holding the Legislature and the rest of state government accountable, she added.
Spear said that rising costs, housing and workforce shortages, and uncertain requirements and timelines inherent in the state’s regulatory structure — such as timelines for obtaining permits — are limiting business growth, employee recruitment and retention, and investment.
A plurality of employers — 35.8% — surveyed for the Vermont Chamber’s 2026 Vermont Business Climate Survey said they were “very unconfident” that state government’s fiscal management and spending decisions enable long-term affordability or growth. Only 0.7% of respondents answered “very confident,” with 11.9% feeling “somewhat confident.”
Through its economic research and advocacy efforts, the Vermont Chamber aims to sculpt Vermont’s business environment to support affordability and abundance.
“The businesses that I meet around the state are not asking government to guarantee their success,” Spear said. Rather, she added, “they’re asking for that fair chance to move forward” with predictability and reliability.
“They need costs that they can sustain, enough housing to support a workforce, public systems they can navigate, and enough predictability to make long-term investments with confidence,” she said.
Spear said reshaping the economy is a long-term effort.
This long-term strategy requires limiting government spending and improving public systems to make them less expensive and easier to navigate.
Growth would come from expanding housing, developing the workforce, and investing in existing businesses, Spear said.
She added that fostering a business climate with transparent regulations and timelines would attract investment and increase Vermont’s reputation as a good place to do business.
Survey tells story of business pressures
Affordability. The concept took center stage in Vermont politics around 2017. Gov. Phil Scott has consistently discussed making Vermont more affordable, proposing measures and policies with claims that they would increase housing stock and add controls to taxes.
But almost a decade later, 135 business owners from across Vermont surveyed for this year’s Business Climate Survey responded that the state’s economic constraints are boxing in their growth.
Those responding to the survey hail from across the state and represent multiple industries. Most reported employing one to four people.
This year, employers collectively ranked the state’s overall business climate lower than they did last year, at 2.62 from 2.86 (out of 5.00). Half of participants said they increased prices over the past year. A third of participants tried to delay hiring more staff, and a third either paused or cancelled capital investments.
When asked to rank the state’s overall business climate, 46.7% rated it fair, followed by 28.9% rating it poor. And 13.3% rated Vermont’s business climate as good, while 11.1% rated it as poor.
No one rated the state as excellent, said Kevin Chu, executive director of the VFP.
The VFP, which emerged from the Vermont Chamber in 2015, is an independent, nonpartisan research organization focused on long-term economic strategy and growth. The two organizations collaborate on multiple projects, including the luncheon at Landmark.
Businesses listed their top challenges: healthcare and health insurance costs (59.3%), workforce (57.0%), housing affordability and availability (48.9%), inflation and rising costs (43.7%), and taxes and fees (42.2%).
The top factors limiting businesses’ ability to recruit and retain workers included a lack of qualified applicants (67.4%), housing shortages and costs (53.0%), and Vermont’s cost of living (50.8%).
The top three state policy areas respondents said would vastly improve their ability to operate and grow in Vermont were reducing health care and insurance costs (54.1%), corralling education spending and property tax growth (33.3%), and increasing housing construction (31.9%).
“When high structural costs outpace household wages, Vermont becomes economically out of reach for the people and families who want to live and work here,” the Vermont Futures Project (VFP) noted in the survey. “Prioritizing these policy areas lowers that barrier, transforming Vermont from merely a desirable destination into an economically viable choice for working families building their futures.”
The full survey and report on the results can be found vtfuturesproject.org/business-climate-survey.
Preparing for 2027
Megan Sullivan, vice president of government affairs for the Vermont Chamber, said she expected a slow start to the upcoming legislative session in January because of leadership changes in the House and Senate.
After the midterms, Vermont’s voters elected several new lawmakers and ushered in a Democratic supermajority, she said. The House and Senate will also be electing a new speaker of the House and Senate president pro tempore. This leadership change may mean new committee chairs and arrangements, she added.
The Vermont Chamber’s legislative priorities this year are fiscal stewardship, unlocking growth, and strengthening Vermont’s competitiveness.
Tax relief must come from more than shifting the burden from one group to another, such as through a wealth tax.
Under the heading of fiscal stewardship, the Vermont Chamber has begun work on a taxpayer’s bill of rights (TABOR), similar to the one Colorado enacted as a state constitutional amendment in 1992 but adapted to Vermont’s needs, Sullivan explained.
Sullivan said such a bill in Vermont would require the Legislature to consider the state’s entire fiscal landscape and the impact of any new spending package, tax, or fee. The bill would also cap state spending. If state revenues exceed this cap, that excess money would be returned to the taxpayers.
According to the Colorado General Assembly’s website, TABOR limits how much revenue the state can spend or keep unless it is “adjusted for any ‘voter-approved revenue changes.’”
The TABOR caps increases based on the prior calendar year’s inflation and population growth. Under the TABOR, Colorado has a flat income tax rate.
Opponents of Colorado’s TABOR, such as the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities or the Colorado Fiscal Institute, say that the measure severely limits the state’s budget choices and that Colorado’s economy has suffered as a result.
Sullivan said a TABOR would help contain government spending.
The Vermont Chamber also advocates for reforming education costs in such a way that maintains educational quality and opportunities while delivering long-term property-tax relief to property owners.
Vermont needs more people to replace its aging workforce and workers who have moved out of state in search of better economic opportunities, she said.
The Vermont Chamber will continue to advocate for reducing healthcare costs, increasing affordable housing, and supporting workers, which will help make Vermont an attractive place to live and thrive, she predicted — for example, improving credential recognition and reducing benefit cliffs that “discourage increases in earnings.”
Many of the Legislature’s regulations, especially in healthcare, have good intentions, Sullivan said.
But, she said, their cumulative costs add up.
“And so I think that’s part of the first thing we need to do is make sure that there is an understanding of what is the cumulative impact of what is getting passed,” Sullivan said.
This News item by Olga Peters was written for The Commons.